Social media rumors rife amid ongoing Gaza conflict

As the conflict in Gaza continues into its thirteenth day, and amid rising casualties (at least 429 Palestinians and 18 Israelis have been killed thus far), we're investigating some of the images circulating on social media to try to ascertain a clearer picture of what's real and what's fake.

If you have a link to a tweet, video or photo that you want to investigate, or help us investigate, then create an account and submit a report.

Update #1

Viral image claims to show brutal IDF warning SMS

The first image below - shared widely on Facebook and Twitter - is a screengrab from a dramatization found on the Raya FM Facebook page. The second image below is from an Instagram post in 2012 - we've added it here to show an authentic IDF warning SMS.

Added by Tom

7 verification footnotes

False by Meedan
TomChanged status to false
Tom

Twitter user @7__r has done some digging and turned up this video clip from the Raya FM Facebook page. The clip is clearly a dramatization, and this image is clearly a screengrab. https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?v=855637941113001&fref=nf More work could uncover if this is the original video, but for now we can mark this image as "false".

Tom

One Twitter user posted a link to this image, which is in Arabic and reads: "The next stage is approaching. Get away from Hamas elements" - this seems a more likely language and message from the IDF (unclear when this image is from) http://972mag.com/idf-sends-text-message-to-gaza-mobile-phones-the-next-...

TomPublished on live blog under UGC misuse rife amid ongoing Gaza conflict
Tom

Fielded this image to Twitter - lots of red flags raised: 1) Why is the message in English and not Arabic or Hebrew? 2) Why is "Israel Army" saved as a contact? 3) This doesn't seem to be in line with other similar IDF messages.

Added by Tom

5 verification footnotes

Verified by Meedan
TomChanged status to verified
Tom

Other photos uploaded to @RanaGaza's Instagram account suggest she was in Gaza in November 2012, when "Operation Pillar of Defense" saw IDF strike Gaza over a sustained period of eight days. Tentatively marking this as verified: It passes the common sense check, +972 is a reputable media outlet, and there are no red flags from reverse image search etc.

Tom

This photo (original here: http://instagram.com/p/SGM62wNABX/) is apparently a photograph from Twitter user @RanaGaza of her father's phone, taken in 2012. The Arabic reads "The next phase is on the way. Stay away from Hamas elements."

TomChanged status to in progress
TomAdded Arabic text message sent by the Israeli army to mobile phones in Gaza

Mississippi braces for tornado

A severe storm warning is in place across Mississippi today - we'll bring live updates here on Meedan Checkdesk.

Update #1

Tornado photos emerge on Twitter, official warning in place

Added by Tom

Added by Tom

6 verification footnotes

Verified by Meedan
TomChanged status to verified
Tom

Again, no red flags from reverse image search and Kyle's Twitter bio and history check out - looks like he's also a student at Ole Miss (which is in Oxford, Mississippi, which also checks out). Great shot! Maybe Brad and Kyle should team up as storm shooters.

Tom

Another foreboding photo - also going to check out the source and run some reverse image searches.

TomChanged status to in progress
TomPublished on live blog under Mississippi braces for tornado

Added by Tom

6 verification footnotes

Verified by Meedan
TomChanged status to verified
Tom

This Brad Lanier looks to be the same chap in the Twitter bio - so it seems feasible that he is where he claims: https://www.facebook.com/brad.lanier.5 Also there were no red flags from the reverse image search. Corroborating photos mean that this looks like the real deal - and what an amazing shot!

Tom

The replies to this photo show that it's been picked up by some channels - including FOX. I'm going to do some digging, starting with a reverse image search and osme investigation on the source.

TomChanged status to in progress
TomPublished on live blog under Mississippi braces for tornado

Aide to Erdoğan pictured kicking protester in Soma following Turkey mine disaster

Alarming images have surfaced online appearing to show an aide to Turkish prime minister Tayyeb Reccip Erdoğan kicking a protester in Soma amid a stormy visit from the PM to the scene of Turkey's worst ever mining disaster, which left 282 dead last week.

Update #4

Aide given sick leave?

Added by Tom

8 verification footnotes

In Progress
melsawy.be7eriChanged status to in progress
melsawy.be7eriChanged status to verified
melsawy.be7eriChanged status to in progress
adminChanged status to verified
Tom

This seems to be based on a Hurriyet Daily news report - it's quoted in detail here, but it's curious that this is the only English language version, and that the Independent are hedging their bets by saying "alleged". Keen to know more about how Hurriyet acquired the source material - it feels "too good to be true".

Update #3

Who is the man that was kicked by Yerkel?

We'd love to hear more about this underreported aspect of this story - please send more info our way if you have it! I suspect it may have been covered more in the Turkish media than English language media, but surely we need to hear from the man attacked by Yerkel.

Update #2

SOAS distance themselves from Yerkel after kick uproar

With much of the UK media reporting that Yerkel was formerly a PhD student at SOAS, the university has moved to distance themselves form any association with the kicking aide.

Added by Tom

Meanwhile, here's another photo - from another angle - of the kick.

It's still unclear who it was on the recieving end of the kick, or what they said to Yerkel to merit such treatment...

Update #1

Yerkal kick image goes viral - can it be verified?

Can we confirm the identity of the kicker and the kickee in this image? Are there other photos from different angles?

Added by Tom

8 verification footnotes

Verified by Meedan
TomChanged status to verified
Tom

Given the weight of reporting in world media, the number of photos and videos from different angles, and an "apology" from the perpetrator, we can say this is "verified", though questions certainly remain as to the identity of the man being kicked.

Tom

This AP report quotes Turkish media featuring a quasi-apology from Yerkel: ""I am sorry that I was not able to keep calm despite all the provocations, insults and attacks that I was subjected to," he said.

Tom

There's video footage from another angle here: http://www.milliyet.tv/video-izle/Basbakanlik-musaviri-Yusuf-Yerkel-vata...

Tom

The man doing the kicking is widely being reported to be Yusef Yerkel, an advisor to Erdogan. This Guardian report has a photo of him alongside Erdogan in Soma (either pre or post- kicking) and it certainly appears to be the same man (face, clothes etc.): http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/may/15/turkey-mine-disaster-aid-pm...

Media for Social Change Unconference

Update #1

Researchers, students, activists, techies gather in Birmingham for M4SC Unconference

Added by Tom

Added by Tom

7 verification footnotes

Verified by Meedan
edChanged status to verified
ed

Raja has confirmed in person here at BCU that she is credible.

ed

However, the notion that hte Meedan team is talented is disputed

ed

I believe Raja to be a highly credible source - she has more than 5000 followers and has tweeted more than 6000 times https://twitter.com/RajaAlthaibani

edChanged status to in progress

Did the Dutch PM Ride His Bike to Meet Obama?

The Netherlands is renowned for its excellent bicycle infrastructre that spans the entire country. It is a common and popular method of transportation for people of all ages, and accounts for 59% of trips within cities. But when Obama flew to the Netherlands to meet world leaders, did the Dutch PM actually ride his bike to meet him?

Update #1

A tweet was shared by around 1500 people showed the Dutch PM riding on his bike, allegedly headed to meet Obama and other world leaders.

Added by Anas

6 verification footnotes

False by Meedan
Anas

While this photo is not of the PM heading to meet Obama, we still don't have info about how he actually arrived to the meeting.

AnasChanged status to false
Anas

Twitter users have pointed out that this photo is actually two years old https://twitter.com/letterror/statuses/448810667777474560

AnasChanged status to in progress
AnasPublished on live blog under Did the Dutch PM Ride his Bike To Meet Obama?

As the tweet went viral, it sparked conversation about the infrastructure in the Netherlands, bike safety, and the eco-friendliness of biking.

Erwin Boogert chimed in asserting that the PM goes to his office on his bike everyday:

The popularity of a tweet invites scrutiny:

Added by Anas

It didn't take long for the origin of the photo to be verified by diligent tweeps.

Mesut Özil and Manuel Neuer: High school team mates?

After Bayern Munich goalkeeper Manuel Neuer saved German compatriot Mesut Özil's tame penalty kick early in his team's recent Champions League match with Arsenal, some pundits questioned whether Neuer's friendship with Özil gave him the edge in stopping the shot and preventing his team from going behind. One photo in particular - published in several high profile news outlets - suggests that the history between the two goes all the way back to high school......

Update #2

Twitter account @Football_GIF makes Neuer-Özil school link

This tweet, posted on the night of the match, seems to be the original source - let's do some verification in the fact checking footnotes.

Added by Tom

13 verification footnotes

False by Meedan
edChanged status to false
edChanged status to in progress
edChanged status to false
Tom

This profile of Özil and Neuer (in German) may hold further clues, but sadly my German isn't up to picking through the details: http://www.welt.de/sport/fussball/em-2012/article106387698/Neuer-unschei... . On the whole I'm inclined to say that Neuer isn't the kid in the photo, but it's difficult to know 100% either way. We await further updates!

Tom

This profile of Özil explains that he and Neuer went to the same school, but that the German keeper was a few years ahead of the Arsenal playmaker. This makes sense when you bear in mind that Neuer is 27, while Özil is only 25: http://www.sport.net/the-making-of-arsenals-mesut-ozil_67387

Update #1

Guardian, Yahoo, Sun show Neuer and Özil posing for a team photograph at school

The photo of Özil - recognizable as a child - and another boy, claimed to be Neuer, has appeared in several international news outlets (in print and online) thus far:

Added by Tom

Embedded image on Dailydot
Added by Tom

4 verification footnotes

False by Meedan
edChanged status to false
edChanged status to in progress
TomPublished on live blog under Mesut Özil and Maneul Neuer: Childhood friends?
TomAdded report-Tom-1393020736

View image on Twitter

Instability in Sinai following removal of Morsi

Egypt's Sinai region has seen continued instability in recent weeks, following the Army's removal of Mohammed Morsi as the country's president. Several attacks against the army and police have taken place, notably in the north Sinai city of el-Arish.

Sinai is a popular tourist destination for western tourists, though many have speculated that the area has also seen an influx of weapons in recent years from the Hamas-run Gaza Strip.

Update #5

Video claims to show RPG attack on cargo vessel in Suez Canal

Video claiming to show the targeting of a cargo ship in the Suez Canal with RPG

Added by Tom

8 verification footnotes

In Progress
Tom

This Twitter account claims this is the statement issued by Kataeb al-Furqan promising more attacks on ships - it must be posted somewhere (Egy media are referring to a statement claiming responsibility) but I can't find the original: https://twitter.com/EgySpecialForce/status/375614551510630401/photo/1

Tom

The video has also been posted by prominent activist Wael Abbas on YouTube here http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=buS4mfEX3w0 and there's a useful comment in Arabic: "That place is probably "Al-Kab" after the "Permit collection area" for the Ismailia-Port Said Road. I say that because I know the area well, I'm from Ismailia and I come and go from Port Said. I can tell this area from the vegetation around the canal. Anyone who thinks that the police and army wouldn't let someone get that close to the canal, let me tell you that the road is only 500-700m away from the canal and anyone can stop their car and go get close to the canal. I'm not confirming or denying the video, just trying to think with you guys."

Tom

There is no visual of the impact of the first RPG, all you can get is the sound of a small explosion. The visual of the second RPG looks a little fishy to me - there's seemingly no damage to the ship and the camera doesn't stick around long enough for a good view of what happens next. I'm going to hunt to see where else this has been posted, and to see if any major news outlets have picked it up.

Tom

Around 3 seconds in there's a blurry visual of the possible name of the vessel on the bow of the ship: Asia. Having searched we can find a ship that matches this possible name: the Cosco Asia. Using marinetraffic.com we can see that the Cosco Asia did indeed pass through the Suez Canal on September 1, 2013 http://www.marinetraffic.com/ais/default.aspx?zoom=9&oldmmsi=356581000&o...

Tom

This video was posted to On Masr channel on Sep 4: first port of call - no pun intended - is to check that there was a Cosco ship in the vicinity in the past few days.

Update #4

Soldier dead in sinai

El-Arish, Egypt (NTN24) - At least four people are shot dead, including an army officer in clashes between an armed gang and the Egyptian army and police in the north Sinai town of el-Arish, according to security sources.

Added by Tom

5 verification footnotes

Verified by Meedan
TomChanged status to verified
Tom

I know this source hes

TomChanged status to in progress
TomPublished on live blog under Instability in Sinai following removal of Morsi
TomAdded One army officer dead in clash in Egypt's Sinai

Update #3

Further confirmation here that the Sinai Sun was the target of the attack, this reporter claiming that the concript who was guarding the hotel was shot dead.

مصرع مجند من قوة تأمين فندق سينا صن برصاص مسلحين #سيناء #Sinai— Sinai سيناء (@muhamedsabry) August 1, 2013

Added by Tom

3 verification footnotes

In Progress
TomChanged status to in progress
TomPublished on live blog under Instability in Sinai following removal of Morsi
TomAdded Twitter / Sinai سيناء: مصرع مجند من قوة تأم...

Update #2

Sky news reports one dead in attack on El-Arish hotel, military/police conscript

Sky News Arabic has reported the attack, claiming that a conscript (could be attached to the police or the army) has been killed.

مراسلنا: مقتل مجند #مصري في هجوم على قوة تأمين فندق خاص بالشرطة في العريش بسيناء— سكاي نيوز عربية-الآن (@SkyNewsArabia_B) August 1, 2013

Added by Tom

Twitter user @iAHMEDsalih claims the hotel targetted is the Sinai Sun hotel

@SkyNewsArabia_B Sina Sun hotel— Free #NGOtrial (@iAHMEDsalih) August 1, 2013

Added by Tom

5 verification footnotes

Verified by Meedan
TomChanged status to verified
Tom

This tweet from a local journalist seems to confirm that the Sinai Sun was the target of the attack. https://twitter.com/muhamedsabry/statuses/362887372121182208

TomChanged status to in progress
TomPublished on live blog under Instability in Sinai following removal of Morsi
TomAdded Twitter / Free #NGOtrial: @SkyNewsArabia_B Si...

This Google Map shows the Sinai Sun hotel in Arish, on 26 July Street.

TT @Fo2ElSoto7 - Translated Twitter Narrative July 26th Ibrahim Gamal Eldin

Ibrahim Gamal Eldin requested translations of his tweets published from the Alexandria Field Hospital on July 26th between 125pm and 440pm (Local time). There are many narratives covering many sides of the tragedy unfolding in Egypt. These tweets tell one story of personal loss amidst the chaos.

Update #2

@Fo2ElSoto7 @deenahsn - very important to have first hand histories right now - we are happy to help record your account for EN audience— meedan (@meedan) July 28, 2013

Added by ed

TT @Fo2ElSoto7 "Tear gas smell filling the hospital, gunfire sound clearly audible." #Alexandria #Egypt @meedan— Deena (@deenahsn) July 27, 2013

Added by ed

TT @Fo2ElSoto7 "Child injured. #Alexandria pic.twitter.com/HGI8uNvNzj" #Egypt @meedan— Deena (@deenahsn) July 27, 2013

Added by ed

TT @Fo2ElSoto7 "one of the #Alexandria casualties. pic.twitter.com/zrEY6teH8t" #Egypt @meedan— Deena (@deenahsn) July 27, 2013

Added by ed

TT @Fo2ElSoto7 "Shot in the eye in #Alexandria pic.twitter.com/larJhqiQYk" #Egypt @meedan— Deena (@deenahsn) July 27, 2013

Added by ed

TT @Fo2ElSoto7 "The number of the casualties is beyond the #Alexandria hospital's capacity. pic.twitter.com/l9Iej6x8af" #Egypt @meedan— Deena (@deenahsn) July 27, 2013

Added by ed

TT @Fo2ElSoto7 "Doctors at Uni Hosp: 50+ injuries in ER in addition to the ones at the reception. All live ammunition wounds."#Egypt @meedan— Deena (@deenahsn) July 27, 2013

Added by ed

TT @Fo2ElSoto7 "@mohamed_tarik I'm at the public hospital, we need doctors and people to check supplies needed." #Egypt @meedan— Deena (@deenahsn) July 27, 2013

Added by ed

TT @Fo2ElSoto7 "3 people died. #Alexandria" #Egypt @meedan— Deena (@deenahsn) July 27, 2013

Added by ed

TT @Fo2ElSoto7 "Worth mentioning there's no Army or Police around/inside the #Alexandria Uni Hospital." #Egypt @meedan— Deena (@deenahsn) July 27, 2013

Added by ed

TT @Fo2ElSoto7 "Accounts of the injured who just arrived conf they were attacked w/automatic firearm,Army unable to intervene"#Egypt @meedan— Deena (@deenahsn) July 27, 2013

Added by ed

Update #1

TT @Fo2ElSoto7 "FYI:none of the injured in the hosp is MB. All accounts of the injured confirm MB attacked'em w/auto firearm."#Egypt @meedan— Deena (@deenahsn) July 27, 2013

Added by ed

TT @Fo2ElSoto7 "Another child among the #Alexandria casualties pic.twitter.com/dBvZLEXSmK" #Egypt @meedan— Deena (@deenahsn) July 28, 2013

Added by ed

TT @Fo2ElSoto7"Big number of casualties can't make it to Uni Hosp, get treatment in makeshift hosp behind Mohamed Ahmed resto"#Egypt @meedan— Deena (@deenahsn) July 28, 2013

Added by ed

TT @Fo2ElSoto7"Big number of casualties can't make it to Uni Hosp, get treatment in makeshift hosp behind Mohamed Ahmed resto"#Egypt @meedan— Deena (@deenahsn) July 28, 2013

Added by ed

TT @Fo2ElSoto7 "Photographer Baha' Al-Din Mostafa got wounded, he's at the makeshift hospital @Boo_Ph #Alex" #Alexandria #Egypt @meedan— Deena (@deenahsn) July 28, 2013

Added by ed

TT @Fo2ElSoto7 "Can hear gunfire around the hospital. Tear gas is filling the air." #Alexandria #Egypt @meedan— Deena (@deenahsn) July 28, 2013

Added by ed

TT @Fo2ElSoto7 "Two more hours to go for my uncle, pray for him." #Egypt @meedan— Deena (@deenahsn) July 28, 2013

Added by ed

TT @Fo2ElSoto7 "Add one more to the death toll, my uncle died." #Alexandria #Egypt @meedan— Deena (@deenahsn) July 28, 2013

Added by ed

TT @Fo2ElSoto7 "My uncle got shot in the back. My uncle is not a Muslim Brother. He just joined rallies like everyone else." #Egypt @meedan— Deena (@deenahsn) July 28, 2013

Added by ed

TT @Fo2ElSoto7 "Eyewitnesses confirm:MB marched in 3 lines:children,women,men. They attacked w/rocks, glass, clashed, then shot live rounds"— Deena (@deenahsn) July 27, 2013

Added by ed

US NSA admits to big data surveilance project PRISM

Update #3

US surveillance programs expanding under Obama

Added by ed

The Guardian reports, "The former director of the US National Security Agency has indicated that surveillance programs have "expanded" under Barack Obama's time in office and said the spy agency has more powers now than when he was in command."

Update #2

Update from the US Director of National Intelligence

The PRISM program is explained in this June 8th letter from the DNI.

"PRISM is not an undisclosed collection or data mining program. It is an internal government
computer system used to facilitate the government’s statutorily authorized collection of
foreign intelligence information from electronic communication service providers under
court supervision, as authorized by Section 702 of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act
(FISA) (50 U.S.C. § 1881a). This authority was created by the Congress and has been widely
known and publicly discussed since its inception in 2008."

Update #1

NSA PRISM legal considerations

Doc says, "I believe Google’s ability to monitor online activities by individuals on a massive scale serves as a model for governments to do the same."

Added by ed

Doc Searls from Harvard's Berkman Center for the Internet and Society has blogged an overview of the debate on the NSA PRISM program.

DNI Statement on Recent Unauthorized Disclosures of Classified Information

Added by ed

6 verification footnotes

In Progress
admin

Test

edPublished on live blog under US NSA admits to big data surveilance project PRISM
edChanged status to in progress
edChanged status to not applicable
edChanged status to in progress

The Director of National Intelligence, James R. Clapper, released this statement on June 6th.

Added by ed

Orin Kerr quotes from his 2011 Brooking Center essay-

The benefit of computer surveillance is that it can process information quickly and inexpensively to learn what would have been unknowable. Assembling and processing information may lead to plausible conclusions that are far more far- reaching than the information left separate. If so, data manipulation can have an amplifying effect, turning low impact information in isolation into high impact information when processed.

Reaping these benefits requires surveillance systems that allow the initial collection and processing. To reap those benefits, the best way to design surveillance systems is to allow the initial collection but then place sharp limits on the later stages such as disclosure.

"The NSA call records program appears to be that idea on steroids: Collect everything, and then control access to the database created. But I’m left puzzled as to what the legal basis is for what appears to be happening. Where are they getting the Terry standard here?"

The Terry Standard being the 4th Admendment standard that defines when the police can justifiably stop a person and question them. If we carried the analogy through, we might imagine that the government assumes it has access to the metadata that tells them what street their suspect is walking down and when - the discretion comes at the point they decide to 'look at the data.'

Ikhwan Online Alexandria Gathering Photo from July 11

Was an old photo used to support the reporting of a gathering in Alexandria last night?

Update #4

The December 19, 2012 Posting Using Same Photo from Alamat Online

اعتبرت مجلة "فورين بوليسي" الأمريكية أن نتائج المرحلة الأولى من الاستفتاء الذي قال فيها 57% من المصريين "نعم" للدستور، تمثل صفعة لمزاعم رئيس حزب الدستور د. محمد البرادعي منسق جبهة الإنقاذ الوطني، والذي ادعى أن الدستور لا يمثل المصريين، ودعا أنصاره للمقاطعة ثم دعاهم بالتصويت لرفض الدستور.

Added by ed

4 verification footnotes

Verified by Meedan
edChanged status to verified
edChanged status to in progress
edPublished on live blog under Ihkwan Online Alexandria Gathering Photo from July 11
edAdded مجلة أمريكية: نتائج الاستفتاء على الدستور في مصر صفعة للبرادعي

Update #3

#fail - Uh Oh - Photo Previously Used in December 2012

@elijahzarwan @Ikhwanweb good eye. This website used the same photo in December. http://t.co/myXwTzbJW6— Basil الضبع (@basildabh) July 12, 2013

Added by ed

4 verification footnotes

Verified by Meedan
edChanged status to verified
edChanged status to in progress
edPublished on live blog under Ihkwan Online Alexandria Gathering Photo from July 11
edAdded Twitter / Basil الضبع: @elijahzarwan @Ikhwa...

Update #2

Sweaters in Alexandria in July?

.@Ikhwanweb seems like it was pretty cold in Alexandria last night with all the sweaters in the picture #fail— Mohamed Younis (@MrMYounis) July 12, 2013

Added by ed

3 verification footnotes

In Progress
edChanged status to in progress
edPublished on live blog under Ihkwan Online Alexandria Gathering Photo from July 11
edAdded Twitter / Mohamed Younis: .@Ikhwanweb seems li...

Update #1

The Tweet from Ikhwan official account

More than 120K protest against #Military_Coup in Alexandria مسيرة بالإسكندرية رفضًا للانقلاب العسكري على الشرعية http://t.co/xB0yqEcoki— Ikhwanweb (@Ikhwanweb) July 12, 2013

Added by ed

5 verification footnotes

False by Meedan
edChanged status to false
ed

Based on the evidence presented by @basildabh in https://twitter.com/basildabh/status/355717333278404608 we can assert that this is a false and mis-attributed image.

edChanged status to in progress
edPublished on live blog under Ihkwan Online Alexandria Gathering Photo from July 11
edAdded Twitter / Ikhwanweb: More than 120K prote...